Library Treasures. The story of “half-hanged Maggie”: ‘The Mourning Necklace’ by Kate Foster
Though an avid history and historical fiction reader, there are many times when I feel extremely grateful to be alive today and not three hundred years ago. The Mourning Necklace is a gripping, imaginative re-telling of a story from the past that confirms that view.
‘Maggie’ in the novel is Maggie Dickson. She was a real person from a fishing village near Edinburgh who, in 1724, was hanged for the crime of concealing a pregnancy. Tragically, Maggie’s baby did not survive and so she was also accused of its murder.
The appalling thing about this story is that Maggie survived the hanging, only to face the very real prospect that she would be hanged again. This much of the story is based on historical fact. Horrifyingly, although rare, her experience was not unique. Hangings could, and did, go wrong sometimes. It’s one of many parts of her tale that makes me so glad to have been born in the 20th century, not the 18th. Usually, the victim was finished off ‘manually’, but Maggie was pronounced dead at the gallows, then taken in a coffin by her family, to a nearby tavern so they could drown their shame and misery in drink. To their shock, Maggie appears at the tavern door, pale, shaking and with a deep welt around her neck from the hangman’s rope.
This real-life event was an impetus to have the wording of the death sentence in Scotland changed from Hanged by the neck, to Hanged by the neck until dead. Obviously, those dispensing justice wanted to avoid any other criminals wriggling (literally) out of the death penalty.
This sounds like a gruesome sort of tale and I suppose it is in some ways, but it doesn’t read like that. The author has taken the themes of justice, the reality of women’s lives in past times, trust and friendship and family, and used the real Maggie’s life as a canvas on which to paint vivid pictures of how she may have ended up at the gallows in the first place, how she survived it, and what happened to her afterwards.
The daily lives of Maggie and the fisher people she grew up around, the smuggling that helped families earn a little extra to make ends meet, the harsh conditions in which they lived and the small ways in which life could be made more bearable, form a rich backdrop to her story.
I listened to the audiobook version, beautifully narrated by Paula Masterton in a rich Scottish accent, full of the warmth of Maggie’s character.
This was another library treasure, as I borrowed the audiobook from my local Blue Mountains Library. Most public libraries offer similar borrowing of audio and ebooks. Such a fantastic service!
For a fascinating and moving insight into a very different time and place , with themes that are nevertheless still timely, I can highly recommend The Mourning Necklace.
It was published in 2025 by Mantle, an imprint of Pan MacMillan.
Related
You May Also Like
